The Female American by Unca Eliza Winkfield, page 121:
My next fear was for the poor Indians, who would come in the evening, and not finding me by the shore…would no doubt come upon the island, in search of me, and be taken for slaves. Nor might the evil stop thus; their country might be discovered, and probably invaded, and numbers of the people be carried away into slavery, and other injuries committed.
“The Most Remarkable and Strange State Situation and Appearance of Indian Tribes in the Great Continent” by Samuel Occam, page 58:
…when I come to look and view the nations of the World I can’t see that they [the Indians of America] are under Greater Curse than other nations…and when I come to Consider and See the Conduct of the Most Learned, Polite, and Rich Nations of the World, I find them to be the Most Tyrannical, Cruel, and inhuman oppressors, and their Fellow Creatures in the World, these make all the confusions and destructions among the Nations of the Whole World, they are the nations that enslave the poor Negroes in Such Barbarous manner, as out do the Savage Indians in North America, and these are Called Christian Nations…
Both of the passages point to the hypocrisy that exists among the English when one considers their Christian ideals versus the slavery perpetuated by the English in the New World. Both Unca Eliza Winkfield and Samuel Occam were trans-cultured Native Americans, and both point out how the humanity of the English is lacking, primarily in the way that the English take slaves. Slavery, no matter how well the slaves may be treated, is still wrong in that it strips humanity of its liberty and rights. In that sense, slavery should be contrary to the beliefs of Christians at this time (or any time for that matter), but instead it is embraced as a staple of “modern” English colonial society.
Both authors attribute knowledge and civility to the English, and yet still understand that civility does not equate to universal philanthropy and liberty. Instead, the English are self-serving, and ethnocentric, believing that all cultures outside their own, especially of non-Christian origins, are lacking even basic human qualities deserving of respect. For example, Unca fears that her Indian friends will not only be taken as slaves but also that “their country might be discovered, and probably invaded, and numbers of the people be carried away into slavery, and other injuries committed.” This passage really reveals her mistrust of the intentions of the English who have stumbled upon her island, and her fears seem out of place with someone who was basically raised in an English community, and spend most of her youth in England. She recognizes that despite the civility of the English, they suffer from a savagery in the form of enslaving for wealth and gain.
Her views are very similar to Samuel Occam, who was not raised in an English society, does not have English blood, and did not spend much time in England during his life. He points out a paradox of nations, as he writes: “I come to consider and see the conduct of the most learned, polite, and rich nations of the world, I find them to be the most tyrannical, cruel and inhuman oppressors.” Such descriptions paint the English in a conflicting manner, since it is hard to imagine a nation to be both polite and cruel at the simultaneously. His disgust is even more apparent when he remarks that “…these are called Christian nations…” In this way he makes it obvious that savagery and barbarism is not limited to only heathens, and such problems occur even with good “Christian” nations. This paradox, however, is not an isolated case with these two Native American authors; this idea is carried through many works of this time as writers try to maintain the Christian values that the English put forth with the savage brutality of slavery that they value.
No comments:
Post a Comment